Take my recipe—PLEASE! (How to make your own Butterfingers!)

OK, you can also buy them from me, but I HIGHLY



recommend making them yourself.

Because if you don’t, we have to make them and…um. I know I’m not supposed to say this, because candy-making is supposed to be all rainbows and sunbeams, but making these is actually rather torturous.

But we’re going to keep making them forever, because they are, horribly, one of the tastiest things we’ve ever made.

After we sent these out to club members as part of the Chocolate of the Month, we almost instantly got a bunch of reorders. Here’s what one said:

Just a note to say that yes indeed, I intended to order 20 of the peanut butter bars. My husband requested one a day for a month, and we compromised at 20. They are phenomenal!


This bar blew my mind! The flaky layers on the inside—not too hard, not too crumbly, not too sweet, just perfect—replicate, nay, upstage and outshine the “real” butterfingers of my youth. This is by far the best vegan candy I have ever tasted. Make it a staple!


OMG I love this bar!! And I never liked Butterfingers. That is all.


I don’t eat candy and I ate an entire one last night. It was so good.


I just had one – and…. Yes, you are going to be making them for the rest of your life!


It really rocked!

So, well—argh.

Here’s the recipe. Please share my pain at what a pain it is.

Let us begin our journey.

Peanut Butter Toffee Crunch Bars

(that’s what we call them since we can’t really call them Butterfingers)

Oh wait, we also call these:

The Ridge Bar

Because their beautiful striated layers are reminiscent of the gorgeous mountain range 10 minutes from the shop, the Shawangunk Ridge, which is famous for its stratified folds.

Enough chitchat.

1. CLEAR THE ENTIRE DAY. You will have 24 bars at the end of this epic saga. We do four times this recipe, and we swear like sailors the whole time. In fact, I whined so much about making these that in the end Maresa took over the recipe (now we call these bars Mareese’s!) in order to save everyone’s sanity from my endless whimpering.

I could just tell she thought I was protesting a bit too much about what an ordeal it was. Because of this, I greatly looked forward to her whack at the ol’ recipe.

About halfway through, she turned to me and said, “You know what? This is ridiculous!!

And I laughed and laughed, safely on the other side of the kitchen, deep into the wonderful world of truffle-making I was ensconced in—beautiful, beautiful truffle-making! How unpeanutbuttery it is! How many you can make at one time! How not molten hot it is! (Even though other chocolatiers gasp when they find out we make hand-rolled truffles—no one does it these days because it’s so time-consuming, instead everyone makes these square thingies with something called a guitar cutter and an enrobing machine, which are fine to make other things but truffles are called truffles because they’re handmade looking, like truffle mushrooms, and round, like truffle mushrooms, and AHHH SQUARE TRUFFLES!! DON’T GET ME STARTED!!—making truffles is pretty much instant compared with these PB bars.)

Here’s Mareesey after finishing a portion of the batch of bars:

Ready to feel the same way?

Let’s go.

Have you ever made croissants? If so, you’ll have a slight jump on this recipe, which is basically the croissant-making technique (puff pastry) crossed with molten hot sugar that requires you to work superfast. It’s a technique called leaf croquant, if you wanna get technical about it.

2. Make your filling.

400 grams peanut butter. We use organic, salted, smooth pb.

60 grams confectioners’ sugar

30 grams cane syrup—we make our own based on this recipe. You could use glucose syrup or corn syrup or probably even brown rice syrup or agave syrup.

  1. Melt pb in a bowl in a double boiler. Add sugar (sift it in) and syrup and knead until malleable and smooth.
  2. Form into a square 10” x 10” (mine in that photo is pretty ragged, yep.). Keep warm in oven.

3. Make your caramel. This is a dry caramel. It takes a bit o’ practice, but it’s a fun technique (I’m not being ironic, I really do enjoy dry caramel making). This photo shows a gross looking scale, because I melted my scale by putting the hot caramel pot on it when I added the cane syrup to the caramel, as described below. Fun times! The scale still works! (It also shows the filling recipe in progress the one time I forgot to sift in the powdered sugar—look at those lumps! Oy. That was a fun batch [I am now being ironic, it was a giant pain.])

¼ tsp lemon juice

450 grams sugar

60 grams cane syrup (see above)

  1. Rub lemon juice into sugar. Make a dry caramel by cooking, stirring slowly but constantly, until sugar is evenly melted and becomes a medium amber color (about 10 minutes. Sugar will not be perfectly dissolved and smooth when the color is medium amber, but if you keep cooking it to try to get it perfectly smooth it will burn and you won’t realize it until later. This is hard to explain.). Turn heat to low, add syrup (it will bubble up, and if you’ve burnt it you’ll realize it now because it will get really dark.), and stir until emulsified.
  2. Pour caramel into a 12” x 12” square on a silicone baking mat (a Silpat) or parchment paper on a full size sheet pan. (DO NOT SKIP THE STEP OF PUTTING DOWN PARCHMENT OR SOMETHING BETWEEN THE CARAMEL AND THE SHEET PAN! I can’t even imagine what fresh hell you’d be into then, trying to scrape magma-like sugar off your sheet pan for the next hour or so.)
  3. Place the square of pb filling onto one end of the caramel, leaving approximately 1” on all sides. Or thereabouts.
  4. Fold mat and caramel over the filling to enclose it.
  5. Peel mat off and tightly seal edges of the caramel to envelop filling.
  6. Put sheet pan in a 200°F oven as necessary to keep warm. You’ll know when to put it in the oven—when it starts driving you crazy and hardening up and cracking, like this:
  7. When it comes out of the oven, the caramel will sometimes get so melty that it spills over, like this. That’s OK. Just work fast.
  8. Roll slab into a thin rectangle then fold into thirds.
  9. Roll slab to ½” thick, to a 12” x 12” square. Fold into thirds again. You’ve done one turn. Repeat steps to do four more turns, putting the sheet pan in the oven as necessary in order to make the dough workable.
  10. Obviously, working as quickly as possible will make your life a lot easier. But try not to burn yourself with all this business of taking pans in and out of the oven and handling super hot sugar dough. Oh, and around the second to third turn, your arms will start really aching. This dough is really hard to roll out, what can I say.
  11. After the fourth turn, cut the 12″ x 12″ sheet into 3 rows by 8 rows, to make 24 bars.
  12. Dip into tempered chocolate (uhhhh…Google it? Buy a tempering machine? Just smear melty chocolate over ’em!).

Just typing that up exhausted me.

Luckily, I happen to have a certain indescribably delicious candy bar right here to pep me back up. HOLY CRAP THIS BAR IS SO GOOD!

19 thoughts on “Take my recipe—PLEASE! (How to make your own Butterfingers!)

  1. Pingback: What I did on my summer vacation. « resistance is fertile

  2. I don’t know what to say – very entertaining but, can I… no, will I? Thank you for your writing, though, it was such fun and made all that folding and sheet action appealing!

  3. This looks so epic!!! When it gets a little less humid around here I’m definitely trying it. Maybe I’ll have a vegan butterfinger party…or…not, and just eat them all myself

  4. I don’t know which I love more… the thought of homemade Butterfingers or your story of how to make them. 🙂 Either way, I will be giving these a shot soon! But not until after the kids go back to school, because (1) I can’t imagine trying this epic recipe with 500 interruptions from my three little ones, and (2) if they aren’t around when I make the candy bars, maybe I don’t have to share them once they are done. Ha! No, seriously. 😉

  5. this has given me a terrible appreciation of what goes into making my new favorite chocolate bar. it’s important for us to know this stuff.

    would the elusive & magical dough sheeter thingy work for this?

    • I’ve wondered that too. I don’t see how it could possibly help because the dough gets cold so quickly, but maybe! I think I’m gonna buy it next month!!! CROISSANT TIME!

  6. Pingback: the curious performance art of being a shopgirl. « resistance is fertile

  7. I do love a confectionary challenge. I made these this past weekend and boy are they tasty. It was a perfect way to spend a rainy day in Maine. Now I want to quit my job and come make chocolates with you.

  8. Pingback: 2012 Highlights (from the entire Lagusta’s Luscious crew!) | Lagusta's Luscious!

  9. I’m sorry Lagusta and company but I will be buying one now. I know, you’re going to curse me, but the mouth-gasm I’ll have will surely make up for one solitary bar you have to make. I hope. Either way, you guys are crazy wonderful: crazy for ever making this a staple bar in your shop and wonderful because you put up with us chocolate peanut butter lovin’, equally as crazy, foodie’s. My heart goes out to you every time you make these. I’d seriously shoot myself.

    • ha! you know what? We’ve got it pretty much down now! Maresa passed the torch on to Lucy and Kate, and they are really great at it. And now we have 4 people who know how to make it, so we can spread the (literal) pain around. I sort of miss making it though, I never do it anymore….maybe I shouldn’t speak too soon.

  10. Pingback: The December Diaries | resistance is fertile

  11. Made them, entirely awesome recipe. I ran my dishwasher underneath the counter to keep the counter warm while I worked. Made things MUCH easier. I also used 225F for the oven temp when heating, using 5 minutes for first two reheats, 10 minutes for second two and 15 minutes for final cut and shape.

  12. I made these! I have something else I want to make, too, before I fire up the tempering machine. Only one 2nd degree burn, which I guess is a win?

    My batch was definitely not encased in caramel — the outsides were definitely peanut butter. They do taste delicious, though.

    Thanks so much for a “real” recipe, and not one of those fake ones!

  13. Hello! First off, thank you so much for sharing the recipe and pictures! I’m a student at a chocolate school and I tried making them the other day for one of my assignments. Man they are a challenge, but I appreciated the warning though! It was an epic fail for me but I’m determined to get it right. Any slight possibility that you would ever post a video demonstration of making it someday? Doesn’t hurt to ask right?

  14. Why does it look like your peanut butter part has the consistency of taffy? How am I supposed to get the peanut butter/confectioners sugar/corn syrup mix off the the one pan onto the caramel in one piece? When I tried this my peanut buter mix didn’t seem at all like yours. What do I need more of, peanut butter, or confectioners sugar? Or maybe the skippy peanut butter I tried to use was the wrong kind?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s